“Joy is quieter than people think it is.”
Meg Shaffer, The Lost Story
Title: The Lost Story
Author: Meg Shaffer
Genres: Fantasy, Contemporary Fiction, Mystery, Romance, LGBT+
Pages: 329 (Hardcover)
Published: July 16th, 2024
My Rating: ★
Read: 7/2/2025 – 7/4/2025

Review:
I knew I was gambling with this book because I didn’t love The Wishing Game even though I really wanted to. I was hopeful when I saw that The Lost Story is supposedly inspired by The Chronicles of Narnia, but I didn’t see it aside from a second realm, and that’s a massive stretch if we’re looking for comparison. The themes are different, the setting is different, the morals are different, the ages of the characters are different, the relationships are different… the two are not even remotely similar.
Jeremy and Rafe went missing as teenagers, and now Jeremy spends his time locating lost children. After the death of her mother, Emilie turns to Jeremy to recruit him to help find her half-sister she had never known about who disappeared in the same woods as him and Rafe.
Like with The Wishing Game, there was an element about the story I couldn’t let go of that spoiled any chance I had of finding enjoyment in the story. In this case, it was just how physical a relationship is between two teenage characters. I’ve written about this with other books that tread into this territory, and it’s just not for me, and I’m put off when I think about an adult author giving this a lot of thought.
I am noticing a trend in new releases where the publishers are giving a very misleading description of the book. I wouldn’t have picked up this book had I known it was going to be a romance. I think it’s a disservice to the author to advertise the book in such a way, but while I’m an open reader, the majority of the audience who picks up the book looking for some Narnia-style magic is not the same audience looking for an elaborate LGBTQIA+ romance. Had I not gone in looking for a Narnia retelling, I think I would have enjoyed the story a bit more.
Likes & Dislikes:
What I liked:
- The cover is so pretty.
- The set up was good but I lost interest when I realized this wasn’t going to be Narnia-esque.
What I didn’t like:
- Misleading synopsis both in comparison and content.
- Like with The Wishing Came, there was a creepy vibe I got from the writing. In both books there’s a plot point that seems harmless at a glance but when you think about it, it’s like… what? (Cannot elaborate due to spoilers in each book.)
Afterthoughts:
I feel kind of bad leaving a one-star review, because it could have been avoided with honest advertising. I haven’t felt this slighted by misrepresentation of a book since Lessons in Chemistry. Like with that book, I might have enjoyed it a lot more had I been told a more accurate summary going in. I’m a mood reader and picking up a book at the right place at the right time largely impacts my enjoyment and rating.

Leave a Reply