“Orion Eckley Darnell, a rock and roll star, devises an unusual plan for escaping the lifestyle his success has forced upon him.”
Goodreads blurb for Orion
Title: Orion
Author: Gail Brewer-Giorgio
Genres: Historical Fiction, Conspiracy
Pages: 356 (Paperback)
Published: 1979
My Rating: ★
Read: 5/19/2025

Review:
I don’t remember exactly where I came across this book. Probably from a YouTube video. I was intrigued to learn that it was this book (along with another by the same author) that planted the conspiracy theory that Elvis Presley faked his death. I’ve never believed this, but culturally, I’ve found its popularity fascinating. (Even recently, a newly released book I read made mention of this theory.) I paid up for a copy given it’s been out of print for a while… now I know why.
To say this book is based on Elvis Presley’s life is an understatement. The entire book is his life play by play with the names changed and a fact here and there tweaked for good measure. While I was prepared for parallels, I was under the impression that the book would skim over the backstory and be about a celebrity exiting the limelight and foregoing his identity. None of that was here.
On top of the flimsy plot, the writing was terrible. When not focused on unbelievable characters (such as Orion’s mother, who basically prophesied that her son would be the second coming), other sections of the book felt as though they were written by a twelve-year-old boy (such as Tuck telling Orion how babies are born).
Super disappointing. I never expected this to be a literary masterpiece, but even for a silly pop-culture conspiracy, this was ridiculous. Not for its suggestion, necessarily, but everything else about it.
I’d been curious to read the author’s book, Is Elvis Alive, but not after this. Besides, after the reading experience I had reading Lisa Marie Presley’s memoir, and the more I’ve looked into this author’s history, I feel like reading a book that went to such great lengths to perpetuate a hoax would be in poor taste. Maybe it had it’s moment back in the day, but now we have access to so much contrary information. A fictionalized take? Fair game. But it could have been done so much better.
Likes & Dislikes:
What I liked:
- Bare bones… the concept and the cultural impact it had.
What I didn’t like:
- The vulgarness.
- Painted a ridiculous picture of religion (namely, various sects of Christianity).
- Lazy plot building. The original concept was built up and barely shown in the last few pages, ending abruptly.
Afterthoughts:
In short, this was 1970s FanFiction. I’m not at all opposed to books that cross over into FanFiction territory (in fact, my recent read, Maria, is one of my favorite books of the year so far), but this was for all intents and purposes, lazy. Elvis Presley’s life highlights were regurgitated into the character of Orion with a ‘plot twist’ ending. That’s it.
(I feel there is no need to tread around spoilers as this book’s legacy is for its ending, and it’s unlikely someone will happen to stumble across this book blindly. It’s a book you have to deliberately search.)

Leave a Reply